Backup and Recovery

by Don Baccus with additions by Joel Aufrecht
OpenACS docs are written by the named authors, and may be edited by OpenACS documentation staff.

Backup Strategy

The purpose of backup is to enable recovery. Backup and recovery are always risky; here are some steps that minimize the chance recovery is necessary:

  • Store everything on a fault-tolerant disk array (RAID 1 or 5 or better).

  • Use battery backup.

  • Use more reliable hardware, such as SCSI instead of IDE.

These steps improve the chances of successful recovery:

  • Store backups on a third disk on another controller

  • Store backups on a different computer on a different network in a different physical location. (Compared to off-line backup such as tapes and CDRs, on-line backup is faster and more likely to succeed, but requires maintenance of another machine.)

  • Plan and configure for recovery from the beginning.

  • Test your recovery strategy from time to time.

  • Make it easy to maintain and test your recovery strategy, so that you are more likely to do it.

OpenACS installations comprise files and database contents. If you follow the reference install and put all files, including configuration files, in /var/lib/aolserver/service0/, and back up the database nightly to a file in /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup, then you can apply standard file-based backup strategies to /var/lib/aolserver/service0

Snapshot backup and recovery

This section describes how to make a one-time backup of the files and database. This is useful for rolling back to known-good versions of a service, such as at initial installation and just before an upgrade.

  • PostGreSQL. Create a backup file and verify that it was created and has a reasonable size (several megabytes).

    [root@localhost root]# su - service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ pg_dump -f /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup/before_upgrade_to_4.6.dmp service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ ls -al /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup/before_upgrade_to_4.6.dmp 
    -rw-rw-r-x    1 service0  service0   4005995 Feb 21 18:28 /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup/before_upgrade_to_4.6.dmp
    [service0@localhost service0]$ exit
    [root@localhost root]#
    
    su - service0
    pg_dump -f /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup/before_upgrade_to_4.6.dmp openacs-dev
    ls -al /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup/before_upgrade_to_4.6.dmp
    exit
  • File tree with CVS. If you are already using CVS, you probably don't need to do anything to back up your data. Just make sure that your current work is checked into the system. You can then roll back based on date - note the current system time, down to the minute. For maximum safety, you can apply a tag to your current files. Note that, if you did the CVS options in this document, the /var/lib/aolserver/service0/etc directory is not included in cvs and you may want to add it.

    [root@localhost root]# su - service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ cd /var/lib/aolserver/service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ cvs commit -m "last-minute commits before upgrade to 4.6"
    cvs commit: Examining .
    cvs commit: Examining bin
    (many lines omitted)
    [service0@localhost service0]$ cvs tag before_upgrade_to_4_6
    cvs server: Tagging bin
    T bin/acs-4-0-publish.sh
    T bin/ad-context-server.pl
    (many lines omitted)
    [service0@localhost service0]$ exit
    [root@localhost root]# 
    
    su - service0
    cd /var/lib/aolserver/service0
    cvs commit -m "last-minute commits before upgrade to 4.6"
    cvs tag before_upgrade_to_4_6
    exit

    To restore files from a cvs tag such as the one used above:

    [root@localhost root]# su - service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ cd /var/lib/aolserver/service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ cvs up -r current
    [service0@localhost service0]$ exit
    
    su - service0
    cd /var/lib/aolserver/service0
    cvs up -r current
  • File tree without CVS. If you don't use cvs, you may want to back up the working directory. The simplest way is just to copy it.

    [root@localhost root]# su - service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ cp -r /var/lib/aolserver/service0 /var/lib/aolserver/service0-before-upgrade-to-4.6
    [service0@localhost service0]$ exit
    [root@localhost root]# 
    
    su - service0
    cp -r /var/lib/aolserver/service0 /var/lib/aolserver/service0-before-upgrade-to-4.6
    exit

    To restore the files, copy the directory back (do this while the service is stopped):

    [root@localhost root]# su - service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ mv /var/lib/aolserver/service0 /var/lib/aolserver/openacs-failed-upgrade
    [service0@localhost service0]$ mv /var/lib/aolserver/service0-before-upgrade-to-4.6 /var/lib/aolserver/service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ exit
    [root@localhost root]#
  • Database Rollback. Restore the database to its backed-up state.

    [root@localhost root]# su - service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ svc -d /service/service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ dropdb service0
    DROP DATABASE
    [service0@localhost service0]$ createdb service0
    CREATE DATABASE
    

    PostGreSQL's dump command does not guarantee to back up all of the procedures and things in the right order for them to be reassembled. In practice, OpenACS users have found that rebuilding some of the common procedures before running the restore usually addresses this. You will see a number of "already exists" errors when you run the database restore; these can be ignored. This forum thread has more information.

    [service0@localhost service0]$ psql -f /var/lib/aolserver/service0/packages/acs-kernel/sql/postgresql/postgresql.sql service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ psql service0 < /backup/openacs/openacs_dev_before_upgrade_to_4.6.dmp
    [service0@localhost service0]$ svc -u /service/service0
    [service0@localhost service0]$ exit
    All commands for a database rollback:
    
    su - service0
    svc -d /service/service0
    dropdb service0
    createdb service0
    psql -f /var/lib/aolserver/service0/packages/acs-kernel/sql/postgresql/postgresql.sql service0
    psql service0 < /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup/before_upgrade_to_4.6.dmp
    svc -u /service/service0
    exit

Back up the file system

Here's a quick manual way to back up a reference install - it should be replaced by an automated script within OpenACS. The command excludes the auto-generated supervise directory, which is unneccesary and has complicated permissions. Make sure that you are using the cron job to back up the database to a file in /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup so that the tar command will include the database.

In the tar command,

  • c create a new tar archive

  • p preserves permissions.

  • s preserves file sort order

  • j compresses the output with bz2.

  • The --exclude clauses skips some daemontools files that are owned by root and thus cannot be backed up by the service owner. These files are autogenerated and we don't break anything by omitting them.

  • The --file clause specifies the name of the output file to be generated; we manually add the correct extensions.

  • The last clause, /var/lib/aolserver/service0/, specifies the starting point for backup. Tar defaults to recursive backup.

[root@yourserver root]# su - service0
[service0@yourserver service0]$ tar -cpsj --exclude /var/lib/aolserver/service0/etc/daemontools/supervise --file /tmp/service0-backup.tar.bz2 /var/lib/aolserver/service0/ 
tar: Removing leading `/' from member names
[service0@yourserver service0]$

Automated Backup (OPTIONAL)

Backup can encompass all files in /var/lib/aolserver/service0. For a development server, putting the files in cvs, and backing up the database nightly, is sufficient. (It's important then to back up the cvs repository!)

Postgres automatic backup

Backing up the database consists of creating a file which is a picture of the database at a particular moment. Postgres can be backed up while running. A quick way to automate database backup is a cron job. This is not recommended for production and is not part of the Reference Platform, because it is not cross-platform and can fail silently. A more thorough solution using the cronjob OpenACS package is planned.

Depending on your overall backup strategy, you can create a series of database backup files, or you can create a single nightly backup file which is then collected into a bigger backup file that includes the other parts of the service (web pages, content, code). To make a new file every night, edit the crontab file for service0:

[service0@yourserver service0]$ export EDITOR=emacs;crontab -e

Add this line to the file. The numbers and stars at the beginning are cron columns that specify when the program should be run - in this case, whenever the minute is 0 and the hour is 1, i.e., 1:00 am every day.

0 1 * * * /usr/local/pgsql/bin/pg_dump -f /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup/service0_`date +\%Y-\%m-\%d`.dmp service0

If you plan to back up the whole /var/lib/aolserver/service0 directory, then it would be redundant to keep a history of database backups. In that case, set up the cron job to overwrite the previous backup each time:

0 1 * * * /usr/local/pgsql/bin/pg_dump -f /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup/service0_nightly.dmp service0

A full Backup/Recovery cycle

On a test service, make sure that your backup-recovery process work. After backing up the database and file system, delete the service as detailed below and then recover it.

Delete the Service

[root@yourserver root]# svc -d /service/service0
[root@yourserver root]# mv /var/lib/aolserver/service0/ /var/lib/aolserver/service0.lost
[root@yourserver root]# rm /service/service0
rm: remove symbolic link `/service/service0'? y
[root@yourserver root]# ps -auxw | grep service0
root      1496  0.0  0.0  1312  252 ?        S    16:58   0:00 supervise service0
[root@yourserver root]# kill 1496
[root@yourserver root]# ps -auxw | grep service0
[root@yourserver root]# su - postgres
[postgres@yourserver pgsql]$ dropdb service0
DROP DATABASE
[postgres@yourserver pgsql]$ dropuser service0
DROP USER
[postgres@yourserver pgsql]$ exit
logout
[root@yourserver root]#

Recovery

  1. Restore the operating system and required software. You can do this with standard backup processes or by keeping copies of the install material (OS CDs, OpenACS tarball and supporting software) and repeating the install guide.

  2. Restore the OpenACS service. Assuming the user already exists, restore the database and files from backup and restore the daemontools link. (Because of a bug in Postgres backup-recovery, not all database objects are created in the correct order. To compensate, pre-creating some objects usually work.)

    [root@yourserver root]# su - postgres
    [postgres@yourserver pgsql]$ createuser service0
    Shall the new user be allowed to create databases? (y/n) y
    Shall the new user be allowed to create more new users? (y/n) y
    CREATE USER
    [postgres@yourserver pgsql]$ exit
    logout
    
    [root@yourserver root]# su - service0
    [service0@yourserver service0]$ cd /var/lib/aolserver
    [service0@yourserver web]$ tar xjf /tmp/service0-backup.tar.bz2
    [service0@yourserver web]$ chmod -R 700 service0
    [service0@yourserver web]$ createdb service0
    CREATE DATABASE
    [service0@yourserver web]$ psql -f /var/lib/aolserver/service0/packages/acs-kernel/sql/postgresql/postgresql.sql service0
    (many lines omitted)
    [service0@yourserver web]$ psql service0 < /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup/database-backup.dmp
    (many lines omitted)
    [service0@yourserver web]$ exit
    [root@yourserver root]# ln -s /var/lib/aolserver/service0/etc/daemontools /service/service0
    [root@yourserver root]# sleep 10
    [root@yourserver root]# svgroup web /service/service0
    [root@yourserver root]#

Other Backup Strategies

Earlier strategies, included here because this section hasn't been fully updated yet.

Set Up Nightly Oracle Exports

(This has not yet been updated to fit with the Reference install. To do so, edit the backup script to save the backup file in /var/lib/aolserver/service0/database-backup). While you're working with Oracle, you should configure it to do automatic exports. An export is a separate backup copy of the database. This copy includes all of the database's state at the time that the export was initiated. If your database is corrupted, you can restore from one of these backups. You should do this step as root.

  • Download the backup script. Save the file export-oracle.txt as /tmp/export-oracle.txt

  • Login as root. The following commands will install the export script:

    joeuser:~$ su -
    Password: ***********
    root:~# cp /tmp/export-oracle.txt /usr/sbin/export-oracle
    root:~# chmod 700 /usr/sbin/export-oracle
  • Setup the export directory; this is the directory where backups will be stored. We recommend the directory /ora8/m02/oracle-exports.

    root:~# mkdir /ora8/m02/oracle-exports
    root:~# chown oracle.dba /ora8/m02/oracle-exports
    root:~# chmod 770 /ora8/m02/oracle-exports
  • Now edit /usr/sbin/export-oracle and change the SERVICE_NAME and DATABASE_PASSWORD fields to their correct values. If you want to use a directory other than /ora8/m02/oracle-exports, you also need to change the exportdir setting.

    Test the export procedure by running the command:

    root:~# /usr/sbin/export-oracle
    mv: /ora8/m02/oracle-exports/oraexport-service_name.dmp.gz: No such file or directory
    
    Export: Release 8.1.6.1.0 - Production on Sun Jun 11 18:07:45 2000
    
    (c) Copyright 1999 Oracle Corporation.  All rights reserved.
    
    
    Connected to: Oracle8i Enterprise Edition Release 8.1.6.1.0 - Production
    With the Partitioning option
    JServer Release 8.1.6.0.0 - Production
    Export done in US7ASCII character set and US7ASCII NCHAR character set
    . exporting pre-schema procedural objects and actions
    . exporting foreign function library names for user SERVICE_NAME 
    . exporting object type definitions for user SERVICE_NAME 
    About to export SERVICE_NAME's objects ...
    . exporting database links
    . exporting sequence numbers
    . exporting cluster definitions
    . about to export SERVICE_NAME's tables via Conventional Path ...
    . exporting synonyms
    . exporting views
    . exporting stored procedures
    . exporting operators
    . exporting referential integrity constraints
    . exporting triggers
    . exporting indextypes
    . exporting bitmap, functional and extensible indexes
    . exporting posttables actions
    . exporting snapshots
    . exporting snapshot logs
    . exporting job queues
    . exporting refresh groups and children
    . exporting dimensions
    . exporting post-schema procedural objects and actions
    . exporting statistics
    Export terminated successfully without warnings.

    If you don't have any warnings, proceed to automate the backups.

  • Automating backups is accomplished using the UNIX crontab facility.

    While still root, run the following command. You can replace the EDITOR="emacs -nw" portion with whatever editor your prefer, such as EDITOR=vi.

    root:~# export EDITOR="emacs -nw"
    root:~# crontab -e

    Now add the following line on a line by itself

    0 23 * * * /usr/sbin/export-oracle

    Save the file, exit the editor. Verify that the addition succeeded by checking the output of the following command.

    root:~# crontab -l | grep export-oracle
    0 23 * * * /usr/sbin/export-oracle
    root:~# exit
    ; Logout

    If you see the line, go ahead and log out.

Set up nightly Postgres exports

This is an alternate method to the crontabls - backup. Dowload this script to /tmp. At the top of the script are several variables that you'll need to customize:

  • bak - location where you want local backups to be saved

  • servername - name of your server (and database instance)

  • ftp_user - username on your ftp account

  • ftp_password - password on your ftp account

  • ftp_dir - path on the remote server where your backups will be uploaded

  • ftp_server - your ftp server

Next, we'll save this file to our server's tcl directory so that it will be loaded on startup. It will automatically be run every night at midnight. Note that this script only backs up the database - not the OpenACS scripts and file content.

joeuser:~$ cp /tmp/acs-pgbackup-init.txt ~/var/lib/aolserver/birdnotes/tcl/acs-pgbackup-init.tcl
joeuser:~$ restart-aolserver birdnotes

That's it! The script will email you with each successful backup (or if it fails, it will send you an email with the reason)

($Id: backup-recovery.html,v 1.11 2003/11/05 11:48:09 joela Exp $)
View comments on this page at openacs.org